Wednesday, August 13, 2014

He's got his eye on you!

Sauron is the primary antagonist of The Lord of the Rings. The viewer is not really given much material to really understand who or what he is other than what is presented in the occasional flashback. The relationship of the Ring to Sauron is never really expanded upon either. I’ve seen critiques, even for the novels, that Lord of the Rings‘ ambiguity of Sauron presents a challenge to the reader (or viewer) – we’re told he’s the antagonist, we see the struggle he presses upon our heroes, but Sauron himself is one dimensional, never present, and never directly challenges our heroes. He’s always there, like a specter via the Ring, but as I mentioned, that relationship is never clearly defined. The movies are even more ambiguous of the nature of Sauron and the Ring than the novels. Today, I will clear that up, but to do that, we need to know the full history of Sauron.

Sauron is not his real name – his real name before his downfall into evil was Mairon ‘The Admirable’. After he came to Arda and fell to evil, the Eldar (the Elves) have given many names for him, such as Gorthaur ‘The Abhorred Dread’, but the one most spoken is Sauron, which is Sindarin for ‘The Abhorred’. The descendants of the Numenoreans call him ‘The Deceiver’ and in Westron (the common tongue, which is a form of Aduniac of the Numenoreans, which comes from ancient Taliska tongue that early men spoke in Middle-earth) he is called Zigur ‘The Wizard’.

Sauron is a Maiar, similar to Gandalf, but Sauron is unique among the Maiar for he was the only one with the ability to change his shape at will, typically a skill reserved only for the Valar. Maiar, when deciding to take physical form, their form is a reflection of who they are. Balrogs are Maiar and their physical forms are dictated by their nature. Sauron could choose to take any shape at any time; he could choose to be a terrible giant, or choose to appear as one of the graceful Eldar, or he could take the form of a giant dire wolf, or a terrible vampire bat.

In the early days, even before the creation of Arda and the universe, Sauron was respected among his peers, and even after his fall into darkness, his lore is still in high regard among those people who inhabit the Timeless Halls; people who care not about the struggles of Arda, which they call ‘The Little Kingdom’. After creation, Sauron went down in Arda – he was excited at the opportunity it provided. He was a Maiar of the Valar Aule. Aule was one of the most powerful of the Valar and was a crafter – he was responsible for the caves, mountains, valleys of Arda and for all the ores and jewels that lay under the earth. His skill was second only to Melkor (the one the Eldar call Morgoth). Sauron was one the most powerful and skilled Maiar and spent many years working with Aule to help shape and form Arda into what it is today – he was held with high regard among the Valar for his tireless efforts and exceptional skill. He was also ambitious, always wanting to learn more and become better at his craft. This ambition is what would lead to his eventual fall into darkness.

In the early days, when the sun did not exist yet, the Valar were contemplating on how would they provide light to world. They decided to construct two giant towers that would have a lamp at the top of them. Aule and Sauron constructed the towers and the lamps and for the first time, Arda was bathed in light. Trees and all the plants sprang to life, animals flourished in the warm glow, and Arda grew to become a beautiful garden of delight, but behind the mountains, were the light never reached, Morgoth dwelt, biding his time. The Valar thought they had thrown Morgoth out of Arda for good, but in these shadows he returned and remained out Manwe and Varda’s sight.

The lamps, in the days prior to Elves (this map isn't 100% accurate of all the lands of Arda)


 With a desire to destroy the lamps, Morgoth approached Sauron. By this time Sauron had grown somewhat discontent – he was starving for more knowledge and lore, but either he learned all he could from Aule or Aule had taught him everything he was willing to share with him. Morgoth, whose skill was greater than Aule, approached Sauron and told him that he could teach him the secrets to the universe and teach Sauron everything he would ever want to learn, but Morgoth would require his service in return. Sauron accepted the offer and shared with Morgoth all of the details of the lamps’ construction and the best way to destroy them. Morgoth used that information to destroy the lamps, causing all of Arda to be consumed in flame, and forcing the valar to rebuild, almost from scratch. Sauron continued to dwell with theValar and kept feeding their secrets to Morgoth, but eventually the Valar learned that Sauron was a spy for Morgoth when Sauron openly joined Morgoth.  

From that point forward, Sauron grew to be mighty while serving Morgoth. He became his second-in-command and the leader of his armies. He became a necromancer, the master of illusions, ghouls, undead, phantoms, werewolves, and vampires. What good was ever in him faded and he became ruthless and vile. Tolkien even hinted that Sauron’s ambitions were to even over throw Morgoth, if the opportunity ever presented itself. He was only loyal because Morgoth was more powerful and he admired strength. It was the first Sith apprentice and master scenario.

During the First Age, Sauron took a back seat to the events that unfolded. While he had a role in many of them, he was never the true designer of those plans. He was always a background threat, in only one story did he play a direct role and that was in the story of Beren & Luthien, but otherwise, not much is described other than he was a brutal servant of Morgoth in those dark times.

At the end of the first age, the Valar moved against Morgoth in a massive war called the War of Warth. Beleriand fell, Morgoth thrown out of the physical realm, many of the Balrogs, orcs, trolls, and dragons destroyed and the survivors fled to the most hidden parts of Middle-earth. Sauron in fear, took on his most fair form and pleaded with the Maia known as Eonwe, the Herald of Manwe. Eonwe couldn’t pass judgement on another Maiar, so he told told Sauron to return to Valinor, and there judgment would be placed on him for all of his deeds. Sauron’s repentance was genuine; whether out of fear or true sorrow for his actions, one cannot say – it’s possible with Morgoth gone, the evil grip was loosened, and he truly was sorry. He was ashamed though, and feared what the possible judgment could be; probably many years of servitude. Out of his shame, he decided to flee and hide in the depths of Middle-earth, wallowing in his sorrow.

The Valar again turned their back on Middle-earth, except the Edain, and helped them establish Numenor. The Eldar and men that decided to stay behind began the process of rebuilding Middle-earth. Seeing a chance to right his wrongs, Sauron returned to Middle-earth after a few hundred years after Morgoth's downfall. He took the form of Annatar, ‘The Giver of Gifts’, and came to the Eldar, who did not know that this person was Sauron – the being that caused so much grief for them during the First Age. As Annatar, he offered great knowledge and lore of craft and magic to the Eldar to help rebuild Middle-earth, claiming that they could make it as beautiful as Valinor. Some had reservations about him, something they couldn’t put their finger on (such as Galadriel and Elrond), but others gladly took his knowledge and learned much from him.

He gained power as Annatar and became to be highly regarded among the Elves, especially the Elves of Eregion who followed Celebrimbor, a descendant of Feanor, but the evil seed that had been planted in him from all those years under Morgoth, grew and began to consume him again. He wanted more power and more control and he devised a plan that would allow him to control men, Dwarves, and even the Eldar. He began construction of the Rings of Power. He constructed the nine rings for men, the seven rings for the Dwarves, and The One Ring (although at the time, he had not handed these rings out). The three rings he did not personally construct. He knew the Eldar were cunning and some still wary of hom, so he decided to have the Elves make them rings themselves, be the maker of their own cages. He had them construct three rings, he provided the knowledge and designs, and they provided the labor. After the rings were completed and handed out, he put on The One Ring and Elves immediately perceived Annatar for who he was; their old enemy Sauron.

He did not expect them to so quickly recognize him. Celebrimbor fled Eregion with the nine and seven rings, as well as the three rings made for the Eldar. He hid the three rings with Cirdan, Galadriel, and Gil-galad. Sauron openly declared himself and went to war with the Eldar. He conquered large parts of Middle-earth, destroyed Eregion, killed Celebrimbor, and retrieved the nine and seven rings, but the three eluded him. Sauron was very successful in his campaigns against the Eldar and things were looking grim for the Elves that remained in Middle-earth, but then the Numenoreans returned to Middle-earth…

Sauron was enjoying the luxury of the Edain’s absence, but when the Numenoreans decided to sail back east into Middle-earth, they turned the tide of the war. Remember, from my previous post, the Numenoreans were more than just mere men, they were essentially a master race of men and they proved that in their battles with Sauron. He was pushed back to Mordor and there he refortified his position. For the next few thousand years, there was constant war in Middle-earth, but during that time, the Numenoreans established large cities in Middle-earth; Umbar, Minas Tirith, Osgiliath, Annuminas, and so on. Their powerful navy filled the bays, the seas, and the rivers. Numenor proved too powerful for Sauron – he envied them, but I think there was a level of respect he had for them that may have simply been rooted in fear of them.

During this time, Sauron had ensnared a few Numenoreans into his ranks via the nine rings. Three of the nine he gave to powerful lords of the Numenoreans – this made them into powerful captains, wizards, and warriors, but in the end, they slowly became the Nazgul and were enslaved by Sauron. The other Nazgul are more than likely Easterlings, men from the lands east and south of Mordor, men who had been slaves to Sauron (and before that Morgoth) for thousands of years. By this time the Nazgul had become a powerful force in his war with the Numenoreans and were his most trusted servants. 

The seven rings he had given to the Dwarves did not result in their enslavement, as he had planned, but it did serve him in the fact the rings caused the Dwarves to be especially greedy and caused vicious infighting among the Dwarven clans. This essentially toke the Dwarves out of the picture of any future war an alliance. Unfortunately, many of those rings were lost as many clans fell into ruin.

Numenoreans were not immune corruption themselves. Sailing back to Middle-earth had earned them many riches and the kings of Numenor became filthy rich and slowly they began to value gold and silver over their friendship with the Eldar. They had risen to such great heights of power and prestige, they felt that it wasn’t fair that the Eldar can travel west into the Undying Lands and they also grew jealous of the Eldar’s immortality. Manwe told the Numenoreans that immortality was not a gift to the Eldar, but just a part of who they are, just like death was just a part of who men were. He even went on to say that 10,000 years of life and even the Eldar would be jealous of men’s gift to depart from Arda. 

Death was a gift given to men – for they are not bound to Earth like the Eldar are – even in death, the Eldar are still bound to Arda. The Numenoreans didn’t see it that way. They felt that the Valar and the Eldar were slighting them. With each new king (with a few exceptions, such as Tar-Palantir and Tar-Minastir) distrust and disdain for the Eldar and Valar grew with each generation. 

The Numenorean aide in the wars against Sauron began to diminish, the Elvish tongue was banned in Numenor, and eventually Elves were no longer admitted into Numenorean lands, and any Numenorean who were still faithful to the Eldar and Valar were considered rebels and imprisoned. The Numenoreans began to openly curse the name of the Valar. This is when Sauron saw his opening to destroy Numenor.

Ar-Pharazon, the most powerful (and final king) of the Numenoreans, was a man full of pride and hate that ruled as a tyrant. One of his advisors, a man named Amandil, was part of Elros’ line, but not in the current line of kings. He was a man that was loved by the people of Numenor, but in secret he was one of The Faithful. Ar-Pharazon knew it, but had no proof and couldn’t have this man, popular with the people of Numenor put intp prison. Amandil did his best to protect The Faithful, but Ar-Pharazon’s arrogance was too much. 

To take advantage of Ar-Pharazon's arrogance, Sauron openly declared himself a God-King of the World, as he knew this would incite Ar-Pharazon, and it worked. Ar-Pharazon gathered the largest army ever assembled and marched to Mordor. Upon seeing the Numenorean host, Sauron knew he could not match the military power of Numenor, he knew if he fought, he would lose. So he surrendered. He met with Ar-Pharazon with his fairest form and pleaded for mercy. He swore fealty to Ar-Pharazon and offered himself to be taken prisoner to Numenor. Ar-Pharazon agreed and accepted Sauron's terms.

Sauron was brought to Numenor and with his fair form and honey on his lips, Sauron eventually became Ar-Pharazon’s most trusted advisor. He spoke in Ar-Pharazon’s ear that Eru was nothing but a made up god to shackle men and that the Valar feared Numenor. He said that the only true god was Melkor (the Vala the Elves called Morgoth) and Sauron being not only the most trusted advisor to the king also became the High Priest of Melkor worship. Numenoreans that worshipped Melkor became to be known as the Black Numenoreans and they outnumbered the Faithful. Sauron began a purge of the Faithful, sacrificing them to Melkor. Many of the Faithful escaped Numenor and sailed back to Middle-earth to avoid persecution. 

Sauron eventually convinced Ar-Pharazon to declare war on the Valar. Ar-Pharazon begin to assemble a massive armda, gathering all of his forces from all of their cities and outposts and the eve of Ar-Pharazon launching his campaign, Amandil broke the ban of the Valar and sailed west to try and warn them – if he made it or not, it’s not told, but his son Elendil and his sons Isildur (a name we should recognize) and Anarion, sailed east, back to Middle-earth to escape the impending wrath of the Valar.

When Ar-Pharazon landed on the shores of Aman, his men were captured to be held until the end of times (for the chance to redeem themselves in the final battle of Arda), and for their arrogance, Eru drowned Numenor and Sauron into the ocean. Sauron lost his body and with it his ability to change shape, but he accomplished his goal. Thus ended Numenor.

After the cataclysm, Sauron’s spirit fled back to Mordor and he reclaimed his lands and his armies. Elendil now found himself as the next in line to be king. The lands of that once belonged to Numenor in Middle-earth were re-organized into the kingdoms of Arnor and Gondor. Elendil ruled Arnor and his sons, Isildur and Anarion, shared the rule of Gondor. While the Numenoreans were re-organizing Sauron attacked Gondor, hoping to take advantage of their weakness. Arnor and Gondor responded by forming the Last Alliance of Elves and Men and the ensuing war ended with the death of Elendil and Anarion, and Isildur cutting the Ring from Sauron’s hand and ending the Second Age.

With Sauron's defeat the Edain was licking their wounds and Anarion’s son became the king of Gondor and Isildur became king of Arnor, although his reign was short. Isildur was attacked by a rogue band of orcs and murdered on his way back to Arnor (and losing the Ring in the process), his son was now the new king of Arnor. With the Ring lost, Sauron’s spirit was weak and he fled into the far east and the Nazgul went into hiding with him. There was once finally peace in Middle-earth.

A lot happened within the next 3,000 years in Sauron's absence – the most powerful of the Nazgul declared himself to be the Witch King of Angmar and went to war with Arnor. Even though the Witch King lost the war, it was so devastation to Arnor, that the kingdom dissolved, and the heir to Arnor went into hiding (this would be Aragorn’s line) and had believed to be killed. The other Nazgul had gathered some forces and pushed Gondor out of Mordor and retook it. They devised and released a plague that killed a large portion of the people of Gondor, in an attempt to weaken their defenses. The final king of Gondor, knowing the Nazgul were behind the fel plague, died after challenging the master of the Nazgul to a one-on-one duel... he was never heard from again. 

The king of Gondor had no heir, so it was believed that the line of kings ended, so the Stewards took over the rule of Gondor in the king's place - hoping for one day an heir to appear. During the Stewards reign, the Easterlings, influenced by Sauron, attacked and nearly destroy Gondor. The horse men tribes of northern Gondor banded together and came to Gondor's aid and turned the tide of the war and chased the Easterlings back into the east. As a gesture of gratitude, Gondor gave all those lands to the horse men, and those lands became known as Rohan. 

Sauron, after gaining strength, eventually returned to Middle-earth, but hid in Dol Guldur (around the time Gollum came into possession of the Ring) and slowly gathered his forces and he became to be known as the Necromancer of Dol Guldur. Many assumed it was the Witch King causing trouble again, and it was at this time the Istari, the wizards, showed up into Middle-earth. Gandalf was able to drive out the Necromancer and there was peace for a brief time, but the wizards began to worry that the activities of the Nazgul were signs that Sauron was gaining strength.

Sauron returned again to Dol Guldur a few hundred years later, this time in strength, a few and Gandalf again went to investigate, in secret, and did confirm that Sauron had returned. The Elves acted and drove Sauron out of Dol Guldur and he fled back to Mordor and started to regain his strength, openly declared himself, and he began hunting for the Ring and for the lost seven Dwarven rings. It was during these events that Bilbo found the Ring, and the rest of that is history.


What is the Ring though, what does it do for Sauron? He made the Ring to enslave the ones who wore the other rings. While wearing the Ring, his own power is amplified, by many degrees, but it gave him power over other's wills. To create this Ring, he put much of his own power into it, so in essence the Ring became a part of him. With it, he is more powerful and without he is diminished. In his final push to conquer Middle-earth, as documented in Lord of the Rings, he was attempting to do it without the Ring, assuming it has been lost forever. If he had found the Ring, it would have been in the final nail in the coffin for men and the Eldar. 

Destroying the Ring destroys the power he put into it. With the Ring destroyed, he becomes nothing of a shadow of malice… a wasted spirit with no power. 

Monday, August 11, 2014

Spring Chicken He Ain't

One of the deleted scenes from the Two Towers was charming scene where Eowyn offered Aragorn a bowl of some foul gruel that she had prepared just for him and he reveals to her that he is 87 years old; much to her dismay. One looks at Aragorn and thinks "This dude is like 40, how is that possible?" - well, it's very possible and in all actuality he's very young for someone of his line. 

Here is the scene from The Two Towers:


Now, what's interesting in this scene, two different kingdoms are mentioned, Númenor and The Northern Kingdom - one in the same, but different. We'll start from the beginning with the days that preceded Númenor. 

During the First Age, men first awoke in Middle-earth, long after the Elves had founded their own kingdoms, in the far east. These first men were ruled by evil tyrants and were pawns of Morgoth. Three groups of these men decided to go west, where ancient tales tell of a land that is blessed by the gods and there they would be free from the darkness. These tales were told to them by the Avari - the forgotten dark Elves, that rejected the Valar and whose encounters with them were only distant memories. 

There were three "houses" of men, the men of Beor, the second was a group of men that would be later to be known as the House of Hador, and the smallest group of men that would become to be known as the Haladin. They all traveled west and passed over the Misty Mountains and then over the Ered Luin and into the land of Beleriand (which no longer exists in the age in which The Lord of the Rings takes place). There they met the Elves, who had built powerful kingdoms and were at the height of their power. So great was the power of the Elves at the time, they had Morgoth's seat of power contained in a siege that lasted many years. Enamored by the Elves, men swore themselves to their service. 

The men flourished in Beleriand and decided to fight alongside the Elves against their sworn enemy, Morgoth. Many battles were fought and many died. Men had proven themselves to be hardy and lethal in war and fiercely loyal. In these battles they made unbreakable bonds of brotherhood with the Elves of Beleriand. The men who fought and died alongside the Elves were collectively called the Edain; the Elf Friends.

Aragorn's lineage begins with one man named Beren of the House of Beor. The story of Beren is sung among the Elves as a beautiful fairy tale of love and it's probably one of the Tolkien's most famous stories outside of Lord of the Rings; the Lay of Leithian. It is a story of Beren falling in love with an Elf named Luthien, from the kingdom of Doriath. People who have seen The Fellowship of the Ring may remember this scene from the Extended Edition:

Here Aragorn speaks about this same story. Luthien and Beren had a child named Dior, and Dior had a daughter named Elwing, who is a very important person, not only in Aragorn's heritage, but in the annals of the history of Arda.  

The other half of Aragorn's heritage begins with a man named Tour, a man of the House of Hador that fell in love with Idril, the daughter of the Noldor Elf named Turgon, the king of the city of Gondolin, a powerful Noldorian kingdom in Beleriand. Their son's name was Earendil, perhaps one of the most, if not the most, celebrated of the Edain in history. 

After the fall of Doriath to the sons of Feanor, Elwing fled to the coastal cities at the mouth of the Sirion river and when Gondolin fell to Morgoth, Earendil also fled to Sirion. There they met and fell in love and they had two children; Elros and Elrond (yes, THAT Elrond). 

There is a whole big story with Earendil and Elwing, that plays an important part of Tolkien's Legendarium that I won't cover here, but what we do need to know here is that Elrond and Elros were a perfect mixture of all three races of men, all three races of Elves, and even of the Ainur (the race of the Valar and Maiar). Here's the break down:

Noldor
Turgon (Earendil's grandfather) was a Noldor Elf

Vanyar
Elenwe - Turgon's wife and Earendil's grandmother

Teleri
Earwen - Turgon's aunt
Thingol - Luthien's father (Elwing's great-grandfather)

House of Beor
Beren - Elwing's grandfather

House of Hador
Tour - Earendil's father

House of Haleth (the Haladin)
Hareth - Tour's mother

Ainur
Melian the Maiar - Luthien's mother (Elwing's great-grandmother)

The results of the events that Earendil and Elwing were involved in, it resulted with the destruction of Beleriand, the end of Morgoth, and a mass exodus of Elves leaving their ruined kingdoms and returning to the Blessed Lands of Aman - leaving men behind in the waste land that was created during these events. Thus began the Second Age of the world. 

Earendil and Elwing were not permitted to leave the Blessed Lands of Aman, but the Valar did grant their children, Elrond and Elros, to choose how their fates were to be judged; either with the Elves and be able to come to Aman and be with their parents and be forever bound to the Earth, or chose to be judged as men, who would never be allowed to enter into Aman and live short lives by comparison to the Elves. Elrond chose to be judged as one of the Eldar and Elros chose to be judged as one of the Edain.  

The Elves lamented that they were leaving the friends they had found in men behind in the ruins of Middle-earth. So the Valar, hearing the cries of the Elves, decided to call for all of the Edain to sail west, to an island called Numenor. Men heeded the call and sailed west and they found a beautiful island, blessed with fertile soil, calm seas, and perfect weather. An island that was closer to Aman than it was to Middle-earth. The Valar gave it to the Edain as a gift. Other gifts is that they made the Edain, taller, fairer, more intelligent, and gave them extra long life (as the gift of immortality was only for the Elves and only something Eru could provide). The only rule that was imposed on the Numenorians was that they were never to sail west and seek out Aman - the boundry of their westerly travels were to remain in site of Numenor. Thus a new race of men was born, the Dunedain - the Numenorians. The Valar appointed Elros to be their king and the children of Elros' line would be blessed with extra long life, even longer than the rest of the new race of Numenorians. Elros ruled the Numenorians for 500 years before laying down his life.

There is a lot that happened between Elros' rule and the fall of Numenor, which I briefly covered in my post about the eagles of Manwe, but the Numenorians sailed east, north, and south, gained wealth and strength and became the most powerful kingdom the world had ever seen, but as they say, the bigger they are, the harder they fall. Survivors of the down fall, that were still faithful to the Valar founded the kingdoms of Arnor (The Northern Kingdom that Aragon mentioned in the first clip above) and Gondor. The king of those two kingdoms was Elendil and his son was Isildur, a man we're aware of from the prologue of The Fellowship of the Ring film, the man who cut the Ring from Sauron's hand and ended the Second Age. Isildur was a direct decedent of Elros, thus Aragorn is a direct decedent of Elros. From Elros' rule to six thousand years later, when Aragorn was born, the Numenorian blood was exceedingly thin, so, Aragorn only lived to be 210 years old, ruling the Reunited Kingdoms of Arnor and Gondor for 122 years. 



Friday, August 8, 2014

Part Two - Deus Ex Mach- I mean Eagles

I had already written most of this previously as a response to this article, which is finding it's way around the internet: 


I've seen this a few times and it's not setting well with me that this might become some sort of default rebuttal to the infamous plot hole in Lord of the Rings. I'm going to clear the air right now, this article is purely conjecture and obviously written by someone not well versed in the Legendarium. There was no plot hole; never was. Granted, if someone had only read The Lord of the Rings, they might think there is one, but we know that The Lord of the Rings was just a small piece to a much bigger whole.

The eagles would never directly intervene in the War of the Ring. The eagles are creatures of Manwe Sulimo; a vala that helped shaped the world - his domain is the 'breath of Arda' - the wind and the air. He leads all of the other valar and all elves see him as their cheiftan, their king. All elves yearn to travel west and to be with him.

During the fall of Numenor near the end of the Second Age, the Numenorians (controlled by Sauron) rebelled against the valar, and even sent armies against the valar, in the land of Aman, in the uttermost west. For their insolence, their armies were captured, and Numenor was drowned into the ocean. 



After all the blessings and gifts the valar had given to the Numenorians, Manwe turned his back on them after they rebelled and cursed the name of the valar, much like he had turned his back to the insolent Noldorian elves led by Feanor in the First Age. No longer would the valar guide men's path - men must strike out their own path and build their own future as the elves slowly moved back west. 

With the rise of Sauron in the Third Age, Manwe, who still loved the Dunedain, couldn't bear that Sauron, a being of their own kind that was still free to roam the world from their own mistakes after the War of Wrath, that ended the First Age, would rule over men as they were weak.



Manwe decided to send some help, breaking his promise (much like he did a few times after the Noldor were cursed), but the help was purely to be counsel and advice. He sent the five Istari (wizards), with Gandalf being one of his own maiar.

The wizards were merely sent to give advice and wisdom to men, but to not directly intervene in the war. This is why they were sent in the forms of old men; they were not there to fight and display their power, only their wisdom (which Gandalf was the wisest of the them). Some could argue that Gandalf overstepped his bounds and became too directly involve in the war, but if Gandalf was in his true form as Olorin, a maiar of Manwe, he would have been able to take the Ring himself to Mordor (if he was able to fight off it's corruption... some would argue, that with the Ring, he would have been even more powerful than Sauron ever was with the Ring).

Now, Gandalf never had direct control of the eagles, only Manwe controls them. The eagles did provide help to Gandalf because he was a maiar of Manwe, but he had no power over their wills. For the eagles to fly the Ring into Mordor would require Manwe to directly involve himself (as they are an extension of him) in men's destiny. The eagles were created by Manwe - they are him. The maiar, in the case of Gandalf, was not created by Manwe, but Illuvatar himself (the being that created everything), but the maiar align themselves with a particular valar (not always though). Even though Gandalf directly intervened, he had the free will do that, a luxury the eagles do not have. Much like Saruman made his choice, of his of free will (he was a maiar of Aule), which went against the will of the valar.

In short, Manwe provided aide, but refused to directly intervene by using his eagles (an extension of himself), because this was man's fight. The Dunedain had a history with Sauron, these events they brought upon themselves (read the Akallabeth), and they needed to triumph over Sauron themselves and create their own future; a future that wasn't dictated by the valar.

Part One - Appendix-ish


Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings film trilogy is beloved by many; including many fans of the books. I admit, I'm a Tolkien nerd - my knowledge is borderline encyclopedic. As I watch his films I take a small bit of comfort in my knowledge of his world and history. To the average viewer Weathertop is nothing more than an old tower that Aragon and the hobbits took refuge during their trip to Rivendell; to me, there is so much history surrounding that decrepit tower that many people simply have no clue of it's importance in ancient history. But compared to the entire history of that world and all of it's lore, it's only a small thing. Knowing so much makes these movies much more enjoyable to me. I have decided, born out of sheer boredom, to explain some of the things, that to the viewer means little, that have such great depth and importance to Tolkien's world. Things like "What is the light of Elendil?" or "Why is Aragorn over 80 years old?", "What's the deal with Sauron?" (his history is one of the most fascinating), and among other things. 

Now, I may know a lot, but there are many more who know much more than I do - but I will admit, my knowledge is still substantial and much of it is commited to memory (even family trees). It really has no use to me, so I might as well make the best of it. Call me nerd if you want; I'll take it as a compliment. 

I will begin this first post simply as a dictionary of many terms I will commonly use in these posts. I will try to post something at least once a week and this will always be available for reference

Legendarium 
Tolkien's collective works of Middle-earth and it's universe.

Arda 
The earth and everything in it.

Middle-earth
The lands stretching from the sea in the west to the Iron Hills, Gondor, and Mordor to the east. 

Ea 
The entire universe.

Sindar
Grey elves, nearly 95% of all the elves in Lord of the Rings are Sindarin elves and their elvish language is called Sindarin. 

Noldor, Vanyar, Teleri 
The three seperate race of elves, most of the Sindar are Teleri, but some are not - the categories of elves is confusing and will be explained in the future. 

Edain
Men who formed an alliance with the Elves during the First Age

House of Beor, House of Haleth (The Haladin), and The House of Hador
The first houses of men to make contact with the Elves in the First Age - collectively, they are they Edain. 

Dunedain
Men of the West - men who were once Edain, but founded the Kingdom of Numenor

Numenorians
Also Dunedain, but these would be ones specifically with Numenorian blood. While Numenor is no more, it was the most powerful kingdom of the Second Age. The kings of Gondor and Arnor decended from the rulers of Numenor. They are gifted with long life (which is why Aragorn is very old and that will be explained in the future). 

Illuvatar
The creator of the universe, Arda, Elves and all beings. Essentially God.

Ainur 
The race of heavenly beings, the first beings created by Illuvatar. Singular is Ainu

Valar
The most powerful of the Ainur, specifically the ones that came down to Arda to shape it and guide Illuvatar's other children; Elves and Men. Singular is Vala. There are 13 total. 

Maiar
Also Ainur, but to a lesser degree to the Valar. The Balrog, Gandalf, and Sauron are some the maiar you see in the movies. 

Manwe
One of the Valar that came to Arda and the most powerful of the Valar still in Arda. The elves see him as their king and men think of him as a god. 

Morgoth
His true name is Melkor, the most powerful Valar and a brother to Manwe, but he was a being filled with hate and malice. The enemy of the world. He created the race of orcs and wargs and all the dragons, drakes, and worms that inhabit the world. While he is no longer in Arda, there is a Raganarok type event that will occur in the future when he will return. 

Aman
The uttermost west. The lands that the Valar dwell in. A blessed land. So vibrant and full of beauty that only Elves may live there (with exception) and the ultimate fate of all Elves is to travel to Aman before they wither away (the true nature of the elves will also be explained in the future). 

Valinor
The largest city of Aman - the city of many bells; and it's at the feet of Taniquetil, the largest mountain in Aman, where the mansions of Manwe and Varda (another Valar) reside. 

First Age 
The longest age, potentially just over 65,000 years (the references get a bit muddle in the early days), it includes the awakening of the Elves and Men and the wars with Morgoth. The last 1,000 years or so of the First Age are where most of the biggest events happened, and when recorded history began. It ended with the over throw of Morgoth. Galadriel was born during this period. 

Second Age
This lasted 3,441 years and was dominated by the Numenorian's rise to power and the beginning of the fading of the Elves. The last half of the Second Age was shaped by constant war with Sauron. The Second Age ended with the Ring being cut from Sauron's hand. 

Third Age
The age that Lord of the Rings takes place. Lasting 3,021 years. It ends with the defeat of Sauron and the destruction of the Ring (technically after all the Ring bearers leave Middle-earth) and the rise of the Re-united Kingdom of Gondor and Arnor led by Aragorn. 

Beleriand
Lands that used to exist to the northeast of Middle-earth beyond the Ered Luin (Blue Mountains), but are now under the ocean. Many of the most powerful elvish kingdoms existed there; Doriath, Gondolin, and Nargothrond. Most of the events of the First Age took place there and the war with Morgoth was so violent, the land was destroyed and sank into the ocean. 

Istari 
The wizards, the most famous being Gandalf the Grey. The others include Saruman the White, Radagast the Brown, and Alatar and Pallando the Blue Wizards. 

That is some of the terms I may commonly use in future posts that will save me from detailed explanation (unless needed). We'll see where these posts take me.